Black Friday 2025: Fear Overtakes Excitement as Shoppers Brace for Survival

Black Friday 2025 is shaping up to be the least exciting and most anxious shopping season in modern retail history. Holiday spending forecasts show the slowest growth since the pandemic, with 77% of consumers expecting higher prices and consumer confidence at levels unseen since the 1950s. The traditional excitement of doorbuster deals has shifted to a more anxious reality. Retailers must prepare for shoppers' mindsets as much as for crowd management. Shoppers coming to stores and websites on November 28 are not just seekign bargains; they are deploying defensive financial strategies to safeguard their budgets and uphold family traditions. Recent analysis by Sooth indicates that almost 40% of U.S. consumers leveraging technology for holiday shopping are driven by heightened financial anxiety. For many, Black Friday is less of an event and more of a last-ditch effort to stretch holiday budgets. Jitters have replaced anticipation as America braces for Black Friday 2025.

‍

ELI's Crystal Ball—5 Predictions for Black Friday, Cyber Week, and Holiday Retail

1. 2025 will mark the end of traditional "doorbuster" marketing. With nearly 40% of shoppers in panic mode and 27% shopping out of obligation, excitement-based Black Friday advertising has lost its audience. Retailers shifting from "amazing deals" to "shop smarter, stress less" will attract most. Security messaging outperforms thrill messaging.
2. Black Friday expands to a 12-week season by 2027. By 2027, retailers will run ongoing "Black Friday Preview" promos from Labor Day to Christmas, transforming the five-day sale into a weekend during a three-month season—with Deal Hunters in September, Panic Planners in October, and Tradition Keepers shopping at the end.
3. AI shopping assistants become mandatory retail infrastructure by 2026. Black Friday shoppers are more anxious than excited, making decision support crucial alongside price and availability. ChatGPT and comparison tools serve as emotional stabilizers. Retailers without AI suggestions, price-match guarantees, and "find me the best deals" features risk falling behind those that offer confidence, not just convenience.
4. Price protection guarantees replace free shipping as table stakes. Panic Planners and Tradition Keepers (65%) aren't just price-sensitive—they're price-paranoid, seeking security against buyer's remorse. Retailers offering "if it drops lower, we'll refund the difference" will lead because they sell emotional security, not just products. Bu Holoday 2026, this will become as expected as free returns.
5. Employers launch holiday financial wellness programs in QI 2026. When 40% of Americans shop Black Friday amid financial terror while maintaining traditions, HR will see productivity costs from Q4 stress. Expect companies to offer budget workshops, shopping stipends, and financial counseling to retain employees, as financially anxious workers cost more than wellness programs.

‍

The Three Types of Black Friday Shoppers Retailers Will See in 2025:

Panic Planners (38.9%)—Shopping from fear, not excitement.

These aren't bargain hunters—they're budget protectors operating in full financial defense mode. They started researching deals in September, have price alerts set on everything, and are using AI tools not for fun but for survival. They want to give their families a real holiday, but they're terrified of costs spiraling out of control. Every purchase decision is accompanied by anxiety. Black Friday isn't optional—it's their only shot at making the math work.

Deal Hunters (34.5%)—Turning shopping into a competitive sport.

The stereotypical Black Friday shopper sees holiday shopping as a game they intend to win, treating price comparison tools and early-bird sales like strategy guides. The hunt itself is the reward—they genuinely get satisfaction from outsmarting retailers and finding the perfect deal. They're not panicked; the chaos and competition energizes them. Black Friday is their Suepr Bowl.

Tradition Keepers (26.6%)—Showing up for ritual, not deals.

They believe in maintaining family traditions and doing right by their loved ones, even when it hurts financially. Black Friday has become part of the holiday ritual they refuse to abandon—not because they're excited about sales, but because "it's what you do." They're stressed about spending, but they're showing up anyway because skipping Black Friday would feel like like letting their families down. Obligation, not excitement, gets them through the door.

‍

About Sooth & ELI

Sooth is the predictive intelligence company decoding the 93% of human decisions driven by emotional, practical, and situational needs. Powered by ELI — Sooth’s exclusive Emotional Logic Interface — Sooth uncovers hidden signals, turning audience behavior into predictive foresight. Sooth’s patent-pending methodology uses artificial intelligence to cross-reference more than 100 million intent signals with data on 300 million individuals worldwide to predict buyer tendencies with 91% predictive accuracy. For more information, visit soothbetold.com and eliwashere.ai.

‍